• Come join us as we welcome Horticulture Lighting Group to the Autoflower Network!

    We have an official representative from HLG that will be active on the forum to answer your questions, several units that are coming for our official product testing (grow and show's,) and we'll be working together to provide better information on lighting in general!

    Come say hello!
  • Do you LOVE AFN?? bighug We do too!! But we need your help to keep the servers running!

    If you feel like AFN has been useful in your journey and would like to help us pay some of the bills, we have a gofundme page setup for donations.
    Any amount that you can spare will be gratefully received

    Click [HERE] to donate to AFN

Why?

St. Tom

chillin like a villain
Staff member
Super Gladiator
AFN Global Moderator
Cultivators Club
Joined
Oct 6, 2016
Messages
17,166
Reputation
4,178
Reaction score
69,604
Points
9,200
Currently Smoking
Whatever s in my jars
im thinking possible salt buildup as i get it a lot on my autopot girls I'm going to call @Mañ'O'Green in as he's our nutrition guy he may be able to work out whats going on
 

Mañ'O'Green

Kia ora. Retired to watch the grass grow.
Staff member
AFN Global Moderator
Cultivators Club
Joined
Sep 15, 2016
Messages
17,796
Reputation
3,978
Reaction score
61,243
Points
1,200
Currently Smoking
Dabs of Rosin.
Well it looks like too much of something or a PH problem. I am working on getting lab equipment so I can figure out the plague we have in autos. I cannot prevent this in my own grows and I just do not know where we are going wrong. I know that the balance in our nutrients is the cause and often for new growers it is too much Cal-mag. I am very careful and still get it. The good thing is it does not stop us from getting a good crop.

I really thought I was hot on the trail and made some changes to my nutrient blend and damn I still got some?

Make sure your PH pen is calibrated and back off on the cal-mag. I will know more in the next few grows as I test the shit out of everything.
 

Goud S!

Auto Warrior
Joined
Mar 12, 2021
Messages
41
Reputation
20
Reaction score
33
Points
0
Well it looks like too much of something or a PH problem. I am working on getting lab equipment so I can figure out the plague we have in autos. I cannot prevent this in my own grows and I just do not know where we are going wrong. I know that the balance in our nutrients is the cause and often for new growers it is too much Cal-mag. I am very careful and still get it. The good thing is it does not stop us from getting a good crop.

I really thought I was hot on the trail and made some changes to my nutrient blend and damn I still got some?

Make sure your PH pen is calibrated and back off on the cal-mag. I will know more in the next few grows as I test the shit out of everything.
I've been pretty diligent about calibrating both my TDS meter and my ph pen. It is very confusing because one article says you can't add too much Calmag and another says be careful and then another says maybe it's a Phosphorus problem... I initially thought that keeping PH in the reservoir towards the 5.5 5.6 end was potentially making the calcium and magnesium unavailable so I have since raised it to the 6.2 range. I think one of my major issues is that I am trying to scale down the nutes based off a feed schedule for photo's. The other side of this is that the time frame is waaaay condensed so trying to match a 10 or 11 week grow off a 16 to 18 week schedule is confusing...where do they correlate and where do I titrate based on age????? I keep testing and try and this one is better than the last run so....I will back off the calmag....but keep the PK13/14?
 

Mañ'O'Green

Kia ora. Retired to watch the grass grow.
Staff member
AFN Global Moderator
Cultivators Club
Joined
Sep 15, 2016
Messages
17,796
Reputation
3,978
Reaction score
61,243
Points
1,200
Currently Smoking
Dabs of Rosin.
Based on my research this is a good starting point for nutrient balance but there is too much latitude. I have stayed in these and still have symptomatic leaves. For sure outside of these ranges you will have trouble. This chart is in weight/l not EC.

Nutrient Guide.jpg


Now about the Calcium thing. Most soil vendors put calcium in as part of the base (long lasting dolomite lime). Coco should be washed and precharged by you or the vendor. Then most nutrient lines have calcium in the base nutrients. In coco you should use nutrients designed for coco and it will have calcium in it at the rate for coco. Then if you use tap water to fertigate with it will have from a little to too much - 100PPMs+ of calcium.

Then we get a new grower with a bottle of Cal-Mag in his/her hand. :yoinks: So you see how easy it is to end up with too much.

That is not the only thing that can cause symptomatic leaves. RH/temp can cause it also - VPD out of range.

Not is not easy being a farmer. Every crop you get across the finish line is a winner.
 

Olderfart

The more I learn, the less I know. :)
Cultivators Club
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
2,135
Reputation
641
Reaction score
4,603
Points
0
Currently Smoking
Vaping: Mephisto 24 Carat, Mephisto Cosmic Queen, and Seedman Strawberry Cheesecake and others.
Based on my research this is a good starting point for nutrient balance but there is too much latitude. I have stayed in these and still have symptomatic leaves. For sure outside of these ranges you will have trouble. This chart is in weight/l not EC.

View attachment 1312176

Now about the Calcium thing. Most soil vendors put calcium in as part of the base (long lasting dolomite lime). Coco should be washed and precharged by you or the vendor. Then most nutrient lines have calcium in the base nutrients. In coco you should use nutrients designed for coco and it will have calcium in it at the rate for coco. Then if you use tap water to fertigate with it will have from a little to too much - 100PPMs+ of calcium.

Then we get a new grower with a bottle of Cal-Mag in his/her hand. :yoinks: So you see how easy it is to end up with too much.

That is not the only thing that can cause symptomatic leaves. RH/temp can cause it also - VPD out of range.

Not is not easy being a farmer. Every crop you get across the finish line is a winner.
Point of clarification - some of the ppm levels in your table are listed as elemental (eg. only the S in SO4 counts), but others are not listed as elemental. What exactly is included in the PPM calculations for these other compounds?

Thanks for all your efforts with this MOG, you are helping a lot of people. :thanks:
 

Mañ'O'Green

Kia ora. Retired to watch the grass grow.
Staff member
AFN Global Moderator
Cultivators Club
Joined
Sep 15, 2016
Messages
17,796
Reputation
3,978
Reaction score
61,243
Points
1,200
Currently Smoking
Dabs of Rosin.
Point of clarification - some of the ppm levels in your table are listed as elemental (eg. only the S in SO4 counts), but others are not listed as elemental. What exactly is included in the PPM calculations for these other compounds?

Thanks for all your efforts with this MOG, you are helping a lot of people. :thanks:
Those are ION that the plant can utilize. The chart is not in EC. It is in weight of ION per liter.
 

Olderfart

The more I learn, the less I know. :)
Cultivators Club
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
2,135
Reputation
641
Reaction score
4,603
Points
0
Currently Smoking
Vaping: Mephisto 24 Carat, Mephisto Cosmic Queen, and Seedman Strawberry Cheesecake and others.
Those are ION that the plant can utilize. The chart is not in EC. It is in weight of ION per liter.
Sorry I was not clearer with my question - I understand what the ppm refers to, weight of the substance per volume of nute mix. What I am not sure of is why the term elemental is not used for all the nutrient ions in the list. If S is listed as elemental ppm to exclude the weight of the oxygen, why is Molybdate not listed the same way?

I'm not trying to pick nits, just trying to understand exactly how the calculations work. For my next grow, I may use a spreadsheet to calculate exactly what my nute mix is during the grow, and the data that you present here will help a lot - if I can make the appropriate calculations from my nute specs. Garbage in, garbage out as the saying goes. :biggrin:
 
Last edited:

Mañ'O'Green

Kia ora. Retired to watch the grass grow.
Staff member
AFN Global Moderator
Cultivators Club
Joined
Sep 15, 2016
Messages
17,796
Reputation
3,978
Reaction score
61,243
Points
1,200
Currently Smoking
Dabs of Rosin.
Sorry I was not clearer with my question - I understand what the ppm refers to, weight of the substance per volume of nute mix. What I am not sure of is why the term elemental is not used for all the nutrient ions in the list. If S is listed as elemental ppm to exclude the weight of the oxygen, why is Molybdate not listed the same way?

I'm not trying to pick nits, just trying to understand exactly how the calculations work. For my next grow, I may use a spreadsheet to calculate exactly what my nute mix is during the grow, and the data that you present here will help a lot - if I can make the appropriate calculations from my nute specs. Garbage in, garbage out as the saying goes. :biggrin:
I believe that as opposed to just an ION the form absorbed by the plant is the element itself. I am not a chemist because I do not want to go down that rabbit hole. You have my permission to venture there.

I have worked on just such a spreadsheet. I have found several formulas to convert the guaranteed analysis to PPM in EC. They don't seem to verify with measured PPM. That said guaranteed analysis is a minimum so you already have slop in the equation. I worked the problem by taking the measured PPM and divide it by the percentages of the GA. I have taken 5 gallons of water and added 10g MC Part A Measured the PPM on the Hanna scale and did the same for Part B. I still have something wrong.

I am supposed to get some Lab Equipment but it is not moving as fast as I am.
 
Top